Anscombe on Sensations of Position

Anscombe introduces the notion of "non-observational knowledge" by taking the knowledge one usually has of the position of his limbs as an example. According to her definition two requirements need to be met when we speak of "observing something": first, we can speak of separately describable sensations (call it the SD condition); second, having such sensations is in some sense our criterion for saying something (call it the CS condition). The "sensations of position"-so called by Anscombe-play a central role in understanding the knowledge we usually have of our bodily position as non-observational. But, do we really have such sensations? If yes, how can we tell whether they are "separately describable" or not? In what sense can having a given sensation be or be not our criterion of saying something? And, why (and how) are the above question to be related to our understanding the knowledge that we usually have of our bodily position as non-observational knowledge? By clarifying the ambiguity in the possible meanings of "sensation of X", I'll try to defend my understanding of Anscombe's answers to the above questions, namely, that we do have sensations of position, and usually they are neither separately describable nor our criterion of saying something-in the sense that we usually don't identify our bodily position by identifying the sensations of position, and that those sensations don't function as clues in our knowing our bodilyposition.That is why we know our bodily position withoutobservation.
[1]Anscombe,G.E.M.Intention[M].Harvard University Press,2000.[2]Anscombe,G.E.M.On Sensations of Position[J].Analysis,22(3).Reprintedin Anscombe,G.E.M.Metaphysics and Philosophy of Mind[C].BasilBlackwell,Oxford,1981,2:71-74.
[3]Anscombe,G.E.M.Substance[J].Proceeding of the Aristotelian Society.Re‐printed in Anscombe G.E.M.Metaphysics and Philosophy of Mind[C].Ba‐sil Blackwell,Oxford,1981,2:37-43.[4]Braybrooke,D.Some Question for Miss Anscombe About Intention[J].Analysis,1962,22(3):49-54.
[5]Harcourt,E.Wittgenstein and Bodily Self-Knowledge[J].Philosophy andPhenomenological Research,2008,77(2):299-333.[6]Martin,C.B.Knowledge Without Observation[J].Canadian Journal of Phi‐losophy,1971,1(1).[7]McDowell,J.Anscombe on Bodily Self-Knowledge[A].Essays on Ans‐combe's Intention[C].Harvard University Press,2011:128-146.[8]Strawson,P.Individuals:An Essay in Descriptive Metaphysics[M].London:Methuen,1959.
[9]Wiseman,R.Guidebook to Anscombe's Intention[M].Routledge,2016.[10]Wittgenstein,L.Philosophical Investigations,4thEdition[M].Wiley-Blackwell,2009.
[11]唐浩.身体性自我知识初探[J].哲学动态,2017(4):73-79.